How a car lease payment is built
When you lease, you pay for the part of the car's value you use up during the lease, plus a finance charge on the money tied up in the car, plus tax. At the end you return the vehicle or buy it for its residual value. That is why two cars with the same sticker price can have very different lease payments: the one that holds its value better has a higher residual and a smaller depreciation charge.
Depreciation fee = (Capitalized cost - Residual) ÷ Term
Finance fee = (Capitalized cost + Residual) × Money factor
Monthly payment = (Depreciation fee + Finance fee) × (1 + Sales tax rate)
Money factor and APR
Lessors quote the finance charge as a money factor, a small decimal such as 0.00208. Multiply it by 2,400 to get the approximate equivalent annual interest rate: 0.00208 × 2,400 = 4.99%. Going the other way, divide an APR by 2,400. Always ask for the money factor in writing, because a dealer can raise it without changing the advertised payment much.
Residual value
The residual is the leasing company's estimate of what the car will be worth at lease end, usually expressed as a percentage of MSRP. A 36-month residual of 50% to 60% is common for vehicles that hold value well. Residuals are generally set by the lender and are hard to negotiate, but the capitalized cost (the price) is negotiable just like a purchase.
Worked example
A $50,000 car with $10,000 down, a $24,000 residual, a 36-month term, a 0.00208 money factor and 7% tax gives a capitalized cost of $40,000. Depreciation is $16,000 ÷ 36 = $444.44 a month and the finance fee is $64,000 × 0.00208 = $133.12. Adding 7% tax of $40.43 makes the payment $617.99. You also pay $700 of tax on the down payment at signing. Buying the same car with a 36-month loan at 4.99% would cost $1,198.69 a month.
Lease vs. buy
| Lease | Buy | |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly payment | Lower, you pay only for depreciation | Higher, you pay off the whole price |
| Ownership | None unless you buy out | Full equity once paid off |
| Mileage | Annual limit, fees per extra mile | Unlimited |
| Wear and customization | Excess wear charged at return | Your choice |
| Long-run cost | Usually higher if you always lease | Usually lower if you keep the car |
Fees to watch for
- Acquisition fee: charged by the leasing company to set up the lease.
- Security deposit: refundable if the car comes back in good shape.
- Disposition fee: charged when you return the car instead of buying it.
- Excess mileage and wear: per-mile charges and repair costs at turn-in.
- Early termination: ending a lease early can cost a large share of the remaining payments.
Taxes on leases also vary. Most states tax each monthly payment, which is how this calculator works, but some tax the full price or the total of payments upfront.
Negotiating a better lease
Treat a lease like a purchase first. Settle the selling price of the car before mentioning that you want to lease, because the capitalized cost drives most of the payment. Then confirm the residual percentage and the money factor the lender is actually offering; dealers are allowed to mark up the money factor, and a small change such as 0.00250 instead of 0.00208 adds roughly $27 a month on a $40,000 lease. Ask whether multiple security deposits are accepted, since some lenders lower the money factor for each extra deposit you leave with them.
Pick a mileage allowance that matches how you drive. Buying extra miles upfront is usually cheaper than paying the per-mile penalty at turn-in. Finally, compare the total of payments plus all fees with the cost of buying, using the purchase comparison above, so you know what the flexibility of leasing is costing you.