How the comparison works
Buying and renting have very different cost patterns. Buying front-loads large costs (down payment and closing costs) but builds equity and benefits from appreciation. Renting has small upfront costs but payments that usually rise every year and build no equity. To compare them fairly, this calculator tracks every dollar each option costs, grows those dollars at the after-tax return you could have earned by investing them instead, and then subtracts what you get back at the end:
- Buying: down payment, closing costs, mortgage payments, property tax, insurance, HOA and maintenance, less tax savings from deducting mortgage interest and property tax. At the end you sell the home, pay selling costs and the remaining loan balance, and keep the rest.
- Renting: rent, renter's insurance, upfront fees and the security deposit, which is returned when you leave.
The breakeven point is the stay length at which the two totals are equal. Stay longer and buying wins; leave sooner and renting wins.
What to expect when buying a home
A monthly mortgage bill is often described by the acronym PITI:
P: Principal
The part of each payment that reduces the loan balance. It builds equity, which you recover when you sell.
I: Interest
The lender's charge for the loan. Early in a mortgage most of the payment is interest. Mortgage interest can be tax deductible if you itemize, which this calculator accounts for when the deduction exceeds your standard deduction.
T: Taxes
Property taxes are set locally, typically 0.5% to 2.5% of value a year, and tend to rise over time.
I: Insurance
Homeowners insurance protects the structure and your liability. Lenders require it, and private mortgage insurance may also apply with less than 20% down.
Owners also pay for maintenance, commonly estimated at 1% to 2% of the home's value a year, plus any HOA dues.
What to know when renting
Renting usually requires first month's rent and a refundable security deposit, plus renter's insurance. The landlord handles major repairs and property taxes, which are built into the rent. Rents generally rise with inflation and local demand, often 2% to 5% a year. The money a renter does not spend on a down payment and closing costs can be invested, which is a real advantage the calculator includes.
Worked example
Consider a $500,000 home with 20% down at 7.118% for 30 years versus renting for $3,000 a month. The buyer puts $100,000 down and pays $10,000 in closing costs, then about $2,693 a month in principal and interest plus taxes, insurance and upkeep. Selling after one year costs 7% of the price, so a one-year stay averages about $76,280 against $37,482 for renting. Each additional year spreads the purchase and sale costs over more time, while appreciation and principal paydown build value, so the average cost of buying falls and the rising rent eventually overtakes it. With the default assumptions, buying becomes cheaper after about 5.6 years.
Should I consider buying or renting?
Major factors
- How long you will stay: the most important factor. Buying rarely pays off in under three to five years.
- Price-to-rent ratio: where homes are expensive relative to rents, renting tends to win.
- Interest rates: higher rates raise the cost of buying.
- Appreciation: faster price growth favors buying.
Minor factors
- Your marginal tax rate and whether you itemize deductions.
- Investment returns available for cash you would otherwise put into the home.
- Lifestyle preferences: control over the property versus flexibility to move.
All projections assume constant growth rates, so treat the result as an estimate rather than a prediction.