Rebate or low APR: the trade-off
Car makers often advertise a choice: take a cash rebate and finance at a normal rate, or skip the rebate and get promotional financing such as 0% or 1.9%. The rebate lowers the amount you borrow today; the low rate lowers the interest you pay over time. Which is worth more depends on the size of the rebate, the gap between the two rates, the loan amount and the term.
How the comparison works
The calculator builds two complete loans. Under the cash back offer, the rebate is subtracted from the price and the loan is charged the regular rate. Under the low rate offer, there is no rebate but the loan is charged the promotional rate. It then compares the interest saved by the low rate with the value of the cash back:
Low rate wins when interest saved exceeds the cash back by $25 or more; cash back wins when interest saved is less than the rebate.
Worked example
A $50,000 car, $10,000 down, 7% sales tax, $2,000 in fees rolled into the loan and a 60-month term. Option one is $1,000 cash back at 5%; option two is 2% financing. With the rebate you borrow $44,500 and pay $839.77 a month, or $5,886.19 in interest. With the low rate you borrow $45,500 and pay $797.51 a month, or $2,350.78 in interest. The low rate saves about $3,535 in interest, far more than the $1,000 rebate, so it is the better deal.
Rules of thumb
- Longer loans favor the low rate, because the rate difference compounds over more months.
- Large rebates on short loans favor cash back. If you plan to pay the car off quickly, the rate matters less.
- Paying cash makes the choice easy: take the rebate.
- Get outside financing quotes. If a credit union offers a rate close to the promotion, taking the rebate and financing elsewhere can beat both dealer offers.
Sales tax and rebates
States treat rebates differently. In many, sales tax is charged on the price before the manufacturer rebate, so taking cash back does not reduce your tax. In others, the rebate is excluded from the taxable amount, which makes the cash back offer slightly more valuable. Select your state so the calculator applies the matching rule, and enter your combined state and local rate.
Fine print to check
Promotional rates usually require top-tier credit and may be limited to shorter terms. Some offers cannot be combined with other incentives, and dealers may be less flexible on price when you take the special financing. Compare the out-the-door price under each option, not just the monthly payment.
When the decision is close
If the interest saved and the rebate are within about $25 of each other, the calculator reports that the offers are similar. In that case, other factors should decide. Cash in hand is flexible: you can put the rebate toward the down payment, keep it as an emergency fund, or use it to pay the loan down early. A lower rate, on the other hand, gives a smaller payment every month, which may matter more if your budget is tight.
Also think about how long you will really keep the loan. Interest savings from a promotional rate assume you make every payment for the full term. If you expect to sell or trade the car early, or to pay the loan off ahead of schedule, much of that saving never materializes, and the rebate becomes the better choice.
One more check: make sure the price you negotiate does not change with the offer you pick. Ask for the price in writing first, then choose the incentive.