What a mutual fund really costs
A mutual fund pools money from many investors and buys a portfolio of stocks, bonds or other assets managed by professionals. That convenience comes with costs, and because they are taken quietly from your balance, they are easy to overlook. Over a long holding period, fees can consume a surprisingly large share of your gains. This calculator separates investment performance from costs so you can see both clearly.
Transaction fees
Front-end load (sales charge)
A front-end load is a commission taken when you buy shares, so less of your money is actually invested. On a $20,000 purchase with a 5% load, $1,000 goes to the sales charge and $19,000 buys shares. If you make regular contributions, the load is taken from each one.
Back-end load (deferred sales charge)
A deferred sales charge is taken when you sell. It is usually calculated on the lesser of what you paid in and what the shares are worth when you sell. With a 5% charge on a $20,000 investment, you would pay $1,000 if the holding had grown to $30,000, but only $500 if it had shrunk to $10,000. Many funds use a contingent deferred sales charge that steps down each year you hold, for example from 5% in year one by 1% a year, so that it disappears after five or six years.
Other transaction fees
Some funds also charge purchase fees, redemption fees for selling soon after buying, exchange fees for moving to another fund in the same family, or account fees for small balances. Check the fund's prospectus for the full list.
Periodic fees
The expense ratio covers the fund's ongoing operating costs: management fees, administration, record keeping, and in many funds a 12b-1 marketing and distribution fee. It is stated as a yearly percentage of the fund's average net assets and is taken a little at a time, so you never see a bill. Actively managed funds commonly charge 0.5% to 1.5%, while many index funds charge 0.1% or less.
How the calculation works
- The sales charge is subtracted from the initial investment and from every contribution before it is invested.
- Each month the balance grows at the rate of return minus the expense ratio, compounded monthly.
- The operating expense for each month is the expense rate applied to that month's average balance.
- Monthly contributions are added at the end of each month, and annual contributions at the end of each year.
- Any deferred sales charge is subtracted when you sell at the end of the holding period.
- The net IRR is the annual rate of return you actually earned on every dollar you put in, after all costs.
Worked example
You invest $20,000 and add $1,000 a month for 5 years in a fund returning 5% a year, with a 2% front-end load and a 0.5% expense ratio. You put in $80,000 in total. Sales charges take $1,600 and operating expenses about $1,323, leaving an ending value of $90,077.09. Your net return is $10,077.09, a net IRR of 3.844% a year, well below the fund's 5% gross return.
Comparing share classes
| Share class | Typical sales charge | Typical ongoing cost | Usually best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Class A | Front-end load, often reduced for large purchases | Lower | Large, long-term investments |
| Class B | Deferred charge that declines over several years | Higher, often converts to A shares | Long holding periods without an upfront charge |
| Class C | Small deferred charge for about a year | Highest | Short holding periods |
| No-load | None | Varies | Investors who choose their own funds |
Run the calculator once for each share class you are considering, using the same return and holding length, and compare the ending values.