What is a pension?
A pension is a retirement plan in which an employer sets money aside for workers and pays it out after they retire. There are two broad types, and the difference decides who carries the investment risk.
Defined-benefit plans
A defined-benefit plan promises a specific monthly income in retirement, usually based on a formula such as 1.5% of your final average salary for each year of service. The employer invests the money and must make up any shortfall. In the US, most private plans are insured up to a limit by the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation (PBGC).
Defined-contribution plans
In a defined-contribution plan such as a 401(k) or 403(b), what is fixed is the contribution, not the payout. Your retirement income depends on how much you and your employer put in and how the investments perform. You carry the investment risk, but the account is portable when you change jobs.
The shift from pensions to 401(k)s
Since the 1980s, most private employers have frozen or closed traditional pensions and moved to 401(k)-style plans, which have predictable costs for the company. Defined-benefit pensions are still common for government workers, teachers, police, firefighters and some union jobs.
Lump sum or monthly pension?
Many plans let you take your benefit as one lump-sum payment instead of monthly checks for life. The calculator values the monthly payments as if you invested the lump sum: each payment is discounted at your investment return, and payments rise each year by the cost-of-living adjustment (COLA). The break-even age is the life expectancy at which the payments' total present value first exceeds the lump sum.
Each year of payments is treated as arriving in the middle of the year, which is close to what twelve monthly checks are worth.
Example: an $800,000 lump sum versus $5,000 a month at 65, with a 5% return and a 3.5% COLA, breaks even at age 81. If you expect to live longer, the monthly pension is worth more.
- Monthly pension pros: guaranteed income for life, no investment decisions, protection against outliving your money.
- Lump sum pros: control over investments, flexibility for large expenses, anything left can go to heirs, and no exposure to the employer's financial health.
Single-life or joint-and-survivor?
A single-life pension pays the most each month but stops when you die. A joint-and-survivor pension pays less, but keeps paying your spouse, often 50% to 100% of the benefit, after your death. Federal law requires a spouse's written consent to choose a single-life option for most private plans.
The calculator looks at the decision two ways. First, how much life insurance would replace the survivor income if you died right at retirement. Second, whether investing the monthly difference between the two options would grow to more than the value of the survivor payments your spouse would receive after your expected death.
Should you work longer for a bigger pension?
Pension formulas reward extra years of service and a higher final salary, and many plans reduce benefits for retiring early. Working longer means fewer, larger checks. The work-longer tab finds the life expectancy at which the later, larger pension overtakes the earlier, smaller one. It compares pension income only, not the salary you would earn by staying.
Cost-of-living adjustments
A COLA raises pension payments each year to offset inflation. Public pensions often include one, typically 1% to 3% or tied to the Consumer Price Index; many private pensions do not. Even a 2% COLA makes a large difference: after 20 years, a $2,000 benefit becomes about $2,972 a month.
Limitations
These comparisons rely on a steady investment return and a single life expectancy. Real life is uncertain, so consider your health, other income, tax treatment of a lump sum, and the security of the pension plan before deciding.