What is an average return?
An average return condenses an uneven history of gains and losses into a single yearly figure you can compare against other investments, a benchmark index or a savings account. The catch is that there are several ways to average, and they can give very different answers for the same history. This calculator uses the two that matter most for real portfolios.
Average return based on cash flow
Most real accounts do not just sit untouched. You add money, take some out, and the balance moves with the market in between. Looking only at the starting and ending balances would credit your deposits as investment gains. The cash flow method fixes that by finding the single annual rate that, applied to the starting balance and to every deposit and withdrawal from its own date, produces exactly the ending balance.
Here S is the starting balance, CFi is each deposit (positive) or withdrawal (negative), and each t is the number of years from that cash flow to the ending date. The rate r is found by trial and error. This is the same idea as the internal rate of return, often called the money-weighted return or XIRR in spreadsheets.
Cash flow example
You start with $10,000 on January 1, 2020, deposit $1,000 on June 1, 2021, withdraw $500 on March 15, 2023, and end with $15,000 on January 1, 2025. Net deposits were $500, so the investment gain was $4,500. Solving for the rate gives an average annual return of about 7.37%, noticeably lower than the 8.44% you would get by treating the whole $5,000 increase as investment growth.
Average and cumulative return
When you know the annual rate an investment earned during each holding period, such as a fund's yearly return or a bond held for a few months, you can chain the periods together. Each annual rate is compounded over its own holding length, then the results are multiplied.
Average annual return = (1 + cumulative return)1 ÷ total years − 1
Here R is the annual return for a period and t is its length in years (months divided by 12). The average return is a geometric average, also called the compound annual growth rate. It is the steady yearly rate that would have produced the same cumulative result.
Cumulative return example
Suppose an investment earned 10% a year for 1 year and 2 months, −2% a year for 5 months and 15% a year for 2 years and 3 months. Starting from $100, the balance grows to about $111.76, then $110.83, then $151.78, a cumulative return of 51.78%. The total holding period is 3 years and 10 months, so the average annual return is 1.51781 ÷ 3.833 − 1, about 11.50%.
Arithmetic versus geometric averages
A simple arithmetic average adds up the yearly returns and divides by the count. It is easy, but it misleads whenever returns vary. Gaining 50% one year and losing 50% the next has an arithmetic average of 0%, yet $100 becomes $150 and then $75, a real loss of 25%. The geometric average correctly reports about −13.4% a year. For judging how money actually grew, always use the geometric figure.
| Measure | Best used for | Accounts for cash flows? |
|---|---|---|
| Arithmetic average | Estimating a typical single year | No |
| Geometric average (CAGR) | Comparing fund or index performance | No |
| Money-weighted return (IRR) | Your personal result in an account you add to or draw from | Yes |
Tips for accurate results
- Use the account value on the exact dates you enter, including reinvested dividends.
- Record withdrawals as negative amounts and fees as part of the balance, not as separate flows.
- Very short periods produce extreme annualized numbers. A 5% gain in one month annualizes to about 80%, which says little about the long run.